Main Discussion Area > English Warbow

Mary Rose replica (updated with full draw)

<< < (3/10) > >>

rudderbows:
Stunning bow!! Mind if I ask How thick are the horn tips ? .

Jaro:
Kviljo, that is fine. One question, could you measure for reference the width taper of last 10" of the limbs in step of 2" for reference?

I think there is some potential of wood removal there.
Good hit on the nocks.

Jaro

Kviljo:
That's nice of you, folks :)

Jaro, you should get the book by Hugh Soar. There's good measurements of two bows in there.

I must say I really wanted to scrape off a lot of wood near the tips. The tiller it has from the measurements are way too stiff-tipped. If it is going to break, it will be near the handle. I think the original is the black bow with the two natural deflex bends at midlimb, so that might be the reason it was tillered this way. I will make it bend slightly more towards the tips, but I won't remove the width as I think that is a more visible part of the reproduction.

I'll get back with the measurements of the tips.

Jaro:
I have read that book and at least two people from the sam archery group I m contributed to it. But I never thought that we should copy blindly anything since no two pieces of wood are the same.
The black bow is favorite of my friend Alan Edwards. It must have been somebodys favorite bow, brought from home, since it does not look like all those fine quality weapons.

My commentary only touches the fact that my personall preference would be making the outer limbs lighter, unless I was  set on making exact dimensionall copy of certain bow - which doesnt have much sense if the wood is not of comparable stiffness.

Let us know how does it shoot.

Jaro

PS - I caught somebodys commentary on short Mary Rose bow, which is Tower - very thick, tapered, uninteresting stick, with surprisingly thick tips. Now that doesnt sound much like, unless it was originally longer bow, which was shortened, without the tips being actually shaved down, the job perhaps inexpertly done. That puts the whole "stiff tips" in different light entirelly, at least with some of the bows.

Kviljo:
The stiffness/density of the wood is unknown, so how then should one go about making a replica, other than copying the dimentions and touching up the tiller by scraping the belly?

Regarding shortened bows - there could be a possibility that such a shortening would be visible on the surface of the bow, if the whole bow wasn't re-scraped totally.
However, I'm not quite sure, because even this black bow is supposed to have had the small ~12mm nocks. If it was shortened without re-tapering the limbs, the non-expert bowyer probably wouldn't fit such small nocks without being aware that the outer 10" of the limbs could be narrowed too?

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page