Primitive Archer
Main Discussion Area => Bows => Topic started by: gutpile on February 22, 2017, 09:46:22 am
-
I just picked up some flat sawn osage boards and have seen few comments about it being bad for boo backed bows. Due to Grain run off...quartersawn is best I know.. my question is can these still make a good bow ?....gut
-
Flat, rift or 1/4 doesn't matter much, grain run outs do. If the grain is straight it will work fine.
-
sweet, I feel better about it .. appears grain runs pretty straight through board.. kinda hard to see on flat sawn...
-
At least you didn't and up with a board like this:
(http://i.imgur.com/JkTXtTW.jpg)
And it was sold a piece of osage to be backed to make a bow.
:(
-
Who sold that to you as such, Ty?
-
Well... I got it from 3rivers, which surprised me because I've gotten osage from them before and the pieces were fairly straight grained (the osage I used for the bow I made for Jeff was from them and the grain was nice and straight).
-
I just bought a piece of osage from 3 rivers that was just as bad. Grain run offs everywhere, board was completely warped, it wasn't worth firewood. 3 Rivers told me the wood was on sale and it should be expected..... Ordered from Pinehollow to restart, they sent me a gorgeous piece of osage that has grain like a leveling stick, and a 2" x 2" x 10" piece for the handle just as nice. Well worth the extra few bucks. Lesson learned. 8)
-
>:(
I've purchased "on sale" osage from 3rivers that was good for bow making (that's why I was fine buying it from them), so that's really a poor excuse.
As far as my board is concerned, the grain is bad, but the board is straight and not twisted, so I think I'll go ahead and just use it for practice. If I can get a backed bow out of it, great, if not, then it'll be a teaching experience (both in bow building and who to purchase materials from...). Heck, I might even save it to turn into core materials for trilams or cut it into veneers for making a bow out of "the material that shall be nameless", as it does have an interesting grain on it (waste not, want not after all).
-
I have made a bunch of BBOs from twisted, tight grain wood with a ton of runouts, never had a failure out of any of them. The bamboo and urac keeps them together.
Matter of fact, if I am making a giveaway BBO it will more than likely have this type of wood in it. I used to call this wood trash osage destined to be a BBO. I have probably made 30 or more with twisted runout wood. There have been a bunch of championships won with these types of trash wood bows that I made, all the way up to the national level.
OK, everyone who has made a BBO out of twisted osage and had it fail raise your hand. What, no hands showing.........
I hate to throw osage away if I can put it to use and BBOs fill the bill.
This is the low poundage BBO I am currently shooting because I had back surgery and I am somewhat incapacitated.
Yep, a BBO with a little runout and about ten years old. When I saw this thread I ran out to the shop and took this picture.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v181/ekrewson/bow%20making/bbo%20runout%20001_zpsdyx3dkoi.jpg) (http://smg.photobucket.com/user/ekrewson/media/bow%20making/bbo%20runout%20001_zpsdyx3dkoi.jpg.html)
-
That's really encouraging to hear, Eric. Just out of curiosity, did you take any special considerations with your design of a bamboo backed Osage bow using a less than choice piece of Osage vs something with really straight grain throughout the board?
-
Nothing at all, I make them all the same. All of my BBOs are 1 1/4" wide and between 62" and 66" NTN depending on how long the draw length is of the recipient.
I have had failures from edge grain osage BBOs that had a pin running cross ways on the limb and positioned little too close to the belly, I had one edge grain without pins fail. I don't make edge grain BBOs any more.
I had two straight grain high poundage (75# plus) BBOs fail that I made for a guy with a very long draw length, after #2 went I sent him his money back and didn't make him a third bow.
-
Thanks Eric, I may try to rescue my hickory trash bow from ringing rocks with some bamboo.
-
Wouldnt worry much about that board... have gottin worse from 3 rivers and have made fine bows from such
-
If you guys start endorsing this type of wood 3Rivers will get wind of it and really start testing things. ;)
-
If you guys start endorsing this type of wood 3Rivers will get wind of it and really start testing things. ;)
Boards with huge knots and holes! Then those of us making BBOs can get as close to a character stave as possible. ;D
-
i have a spare bamboo back, your sentiments are encouraging me to try to work through the issues of my 3rivers osage scrap. I may be able to cut it down to 60" twist out the remaining warp and back it with the bamboo to see what I can salvage from it. Better to give a short decent bow to a friend for free than sit on my shelf and remind me of a failed project.
-
Eric your post gives me hope on some of these boards.. appears they were cut off a large limb