Primitive Archer
Main Discussion Area => Bows => Topic started by: fisher2 on May 19, 2013, 04:00:00 am
-
how heavy can you make a board bow
red oak?
maple?
-
depends on how good the grain of the board is and how wide you make it and how thick you make it.
-
How heavy a bow do you want to make ???
-
Here are a couple questions you should answer for yourself. I don't know you, so I apologize if this isn't helpful.
#1- What do you want this bow for? target shooting, flight competition, hunting, historical replication, showing people how strong you are? Make sure you're building the right bow for the right reasons.
#2 How much experience do you have building bows? Heavy weight bows are difficult to make and dangerous.
-
Fisher, you've asked a similar question before. I'm not really liking your style of asking similar questions in different sub-forums of this message board. Please try to work with us, instead of against us. We keep asking you questions, since you fail to deliver sufficient information to give you a meaningful answer.
How heavy for a red oak board 'bow'? Technically there is no maximum. 300 pounds should be no problem.
How heavy for a maple board 'bow'? Technically there is no maximum. 300 pounds should be no problem.
The key is in the dimensions of the bow. A 200# board bow should measure at least 85" or so to deal with the strain.
-
Here are a couple questions you should answer for yourself. I don't know you, so I apologize if this isn't helpful.
#1- What do you want this bow for? target shooting, flight competition, hunting, historical replication, showing people how strong you are? Make sure you're building the right bow for the right reasons.
#2 How much experience do you have building bows? Heavy weight bows are difficult to make and dangerous.
#1 i use bows 75+# for everything from 300 round paper punching to fishing for turtles so naturally i want to try to make a bow in that weight range
the reason i shoot that weight is solely because i enjoy the challenge of up keeping the needed strength to even shoot a 300 round or a 3d round without fatigue i know theres a bonus in penetration of animals if i ever get a shot at one( which i havnt but i score 230-240 on the 28 target 3d courses)
2. i havnt made many bows at all but all of my board bows have lasted and are still flinging arrows a few months later so far they're ugly as sin but they fling an arrow
-
how heavy can you make a board bow
red oak?
maple?
That's like asking how long can you make a piece of rope. Depends what kind of 'board bow' you want. I have made tri-lam 'board bows' up to 120#. It's all about wood selection, design, and tillering.
-
..."It's all about wood selection, design, and tillering"...just like any other type of wood bow! ;)
-
Amen, brother.
-
so if i get a redoak board and cut it at 72" i can safely make a 100# bow? out of a 1x2 or would i need it longer
-
For red oak i'd find a perfect board and the densest I can find for 100#. At LEAST 72" in length. Then back it with linen for added security ;) just kiddn, I wouldn't make a 100# bow with anything less than a perfect specimen. then i would have someone else tiller and shoot it for me :o
-
now here's a stupid question what is "dense" is that more rings or less?
-
I think rings (you want thick) would only give you a rough estimate, try to find a especially heavy peice
-
so if i get a redoak board and cut it at 72" i can safely make a 100# bow? out of a 1x2 or would i need it longer
I doubt that honestly
-
I'd start out with a 2x2@72" to get a heavy bow out of it. You would be better off going longer though.
-
go by feel for density (unless you wanna take a scale with ya!), but you want a board heavy for its size. It should have thin early growth (porous), and thick late growth. 2" width minimum I would say, keep in mind a 2" finished board is actually 1.75".
Do a search on here as well, i think i remember someone doing a heavy RO board a while back?
-
If I was going to build a 100# bow, it wouldn't be oak, and it wouldn't be 72".
-
If I was going to build a 100# bow, it wouldn't be oak, and it wouldn't be 72".
+1 I hate red oak, I just use it cause its cheap and most readily available to me. None of my stuff is over 50# and I wouldn't trust it over that. At least not from a board. Of course people have built red oak stuff well into the 70# it's just my personal opinion.
Jon
-
+1 I hate red oak, I just use it cause its cheap and most readily available to me. None of my stuff is over 50# and I wouldn't trust it over that. At least not from a board. Of course people have built red oak stuff well into the 70# it's just my personal opinion.
Jon
I hear ya it seems like I get the boards pulling over 55# - 60# and they end up breaking. I'm talking like 66" stiff handle bows, Maybe just maybe I can get a board bow to pull 60# if bendy handle like 64-68" long. Thats my 2 cents.