Im not disagreeing Mike, just giving my experience. Ive made well in excess of 2000 arrows and never used a tester of any sorts, beyond my hands spaced 26" apart. Ive also sent them around to several pretty good shots with great feedback. I hunt and that's all I do with my gear and the only reason I build anything. If I didn't have great accuracy and flight I surely wouldn't hunt with them and I surely wouldn't have a full freezer every year for the last 26 and counting! I also think experience counts for something in our craft. Albeit bowyery or arrow smithing.
I've made a few shafts as well! Around about the same amount as you in fact. Maybe even a few more
I think experience is one of the most valuable assets there is too. In any field.
I can shoot well enough with unmatched shafts but I know for a fact that I can shoot better with weight, spine and p.o.b. matched shafts. That's my experience and like i said we will have to agree to disagree. Unfortunately without a shooting machine that imitates the human hand it's all a little bit subjective.